Skip to main content

How can a turned-off phone be harmful?

 

How can a turned-off phone be harmful? Yes, this is not a typo)) We all know that smartphone addiction is dangerous for our mental health (increased anxiety, etc.), physical health (sedentary lifestyle), and social health (deterioration of relationships). But it is important to remember that even a turned off phone can have a negative impact on our cognitive abilities and our relationships.

Scientists call this the “mere presence effect”. When a phone is within sight (even if it is upside down), it still leads to us expending additional cognitive resources on it (thinking about who might have messaged or liked something, resisting the temptation to check it, etc.). All of this leaves fewer cognitive resources available for other tasks. Therefore, in studies, participants perform worse on tests of learning, memory, and attention when a phone is within sight compared to when a notebook is within sight.

When we talk to people, the presence of a phone (even a turned off one) also leads to a lower quality of communication. Intimacy, significance, trust, and empathy all decrease. The closer the conversation partner and the more important the conversation, the greater the negative impact on communication quality. The possible mechanism is cognitive distortion, which impairs our ability to reflect on and understand the conversation partner, or frequent diversion of our gaze to the phone. Simply glancing at the phone for a second breaks eye contact and can reduce the release of oxytocin, which impairs the feeling of connection between conversation partners.

So, what should you do?

  1. Understand that the mere presence of a turned-off phone already affects your behavior.

Those who suffer more from smartphone addiction benefit from its absence from sight.

2. A phone in silent mode, upside down, or turned off (but within sight) does not work. It is better to keep it in a bag or drawer, but it is even better not to have it in the room at all.

3. Keeping the phone out of sight can have very positive effects on your cognitive abilities and improve the quality of communication. Do not touch your phone during conversations.

Mobile phones: The effect of its presence on learning and memory PLoS One. 2020; 15(8): e0219233.

PLoS One. 2020; 15(8): e0219233. Mobile phones: The effect of its presence on learning and memory

Brain Drain: The Mere Presence of One’s Own Smartphone Reduces Available Cognitive Capacity

Can you connect with me now? How the presence of mobile communication technology influences face-to-face conversation quality Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 30(3)

How bad is the mere presence of a phone? A replication of Przybylski and Weinstein (2013) and an extension to creativity PLoS One. 2021; 16(6): e0251451.

The iPhone effect: The quality of in-person social interactions in the presence of mobile devices. Environ Behav. 2016. Feb;48(2): 275–298.

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

The dopamine-serotonin swing: from drugs to ideologies.

The dopamine-serotonin swing: from drugs to  ideologies. Our brain uses different neurotransmitter systems to interact with what lies at a distance from us. There's the “here-and-now, accessible” the liking system (oxytocin, endorphins, serotonin) – and the “future, not-here, unavailable” system – the wanting system (dopamine). The first system is active when we’re mindful, accepting reality, and present. When we slip into rumination, anxiety, or fantasy, the second system kicks in. Typically, we live mostly in the present, occasionally switching to the dopamine system for goal-setting, desires, forecasting, and planning, and then return to the present (this is a simplified explanation). Historically, escaping from reality was difficult due to its intense demands – survival, food gathering, mating, navigating threats – forcing us to remain grounded in the “here-and-now” with only brief ventures into fantasy. This created a vulnerability in our brains: a lack of brakes when consciou...
Read more

Seven ideas for healthy rest

  Seven ideas for healthy, efficient rest:   1. Preventive rest instead of burnout recovery.  The sooner you start taking breaks and resting, the longer you can work without exhaustion. The idea of "resting only when everything is finished" is flawed. Breaks aren't a waste of time; they’re like "sharpening the saw." Keep your brain in good shape, and don’t overload it.   2. Planned rest instead of whatever comes up.    The ideal rest is one that you plan ahead. Try scheduling recreational activities first in your weekly planner. Outline where and how you'll relax, make time for hobbies and enjoyable tasks. Then, fit your work around that.   3. Changing context instead of monotony.    Working and resting at the same desk is a bad idea. Use different environments for different activities. Traveling somewhere without work-related associations is an effective way to recharge.       4. Take a full rest instead of “half-work.”  ...
Read more